If you are thinking about learning to fly, you will hear a lot about flight simulators. “Sim hours count toward your licence.” “A good simulator is as good as the real aircraft.” “You can do your instrument rating almost entirely on the ground.” Some of these statements are partly true, some depend heavily on where you train, and some are simply sales talk. This plain-language explainer walks through common simulator training claims and shows you how to check each one against the source that actually decides the answer.
First, what do people mean by “simulator”?
The word covers a huge range of equipment. At one end you have a home flight-sim setup on a gaming PC. At the other you have full-motion devices used by airlines. In between sit the fixed-base training devices many flight schools use, with real-looking panels, accurate instrument behaviour and an instructor station.
This matters because a claim like “simulator time counts” means nothing until you know which kind of device is being talked about. Regulators generally classify training devices into categories, and each category is approved for specific tasks. A device approved for some instrument procedures may not be approved for others.
For a feel of what school-level equipment looks like, you can read about the Frasca device our academy brought in for instrument work.
Claim 1: “Sim hours count toward your licence”
The honest answer is “some of them can, under specific rules.” How many hours, for which licence or rating, and on which category of device is set by your civil aviation authority, not by the school, the manufacturer or a friend who trained somewhere else.
How to check it: Ask which exact device will be used and what its approval covers. Then look up the current regulation from your own aviation authority for the licence you are aiming at. If the school tells you a number, ask them to show you where it comes from. A good school will be happy to do that.
Keep in mind that rules get revised. A figure a friend quoted from their training a few years ago may no longer match the current version, so check the date on whatever you read.
Claim 2: “A great simulator is as good as flying”
Modern devices are impressive. They can reproduce instrument indications, failures and weather scenarios that would be unsafe or impossible to practise in a real aircraft. That is a genuine strength.
But “as good as flying” is a big statement. Simulators differ in how they handle the feel of the controls, motion cues, visual depth and the small sensations pilots learn to notice. Many devices are excellent for procedures and decision-making, and less representative for certain hands-on skills.
How to check it: Treat “as good as” as an opinion. Ask what tasks the device is best for, and what tasks the school still does in the aircraft. The answer tells you far more than any adjective.
Claim 3: “This simulator replicates lots of aircraft types”
Some training devices can be configured to represent many aircraft. That flexibility is useful for practising procedures across different panel layouts. You can read about one example in our post on the multi-aircraft Alsim device used for instrument and upset practice.
How to check it: Ask how each configuration is approved. Being able to display a type on screen is different from being approved to log training time in that configuration. The approval documentation, not the brochure, answers this.
Claim 4: “Everyone finishes the rating in X weeks thanks to the sim”
Speed claims are everywhere in flight training. They are rarely wrong in the sense of being invented, but they are often the fastest case rather than the typical one. Weather, aircraft availability, how often you can train and how quickly you personally absorb new skills all change the timeline.
How to check it: Ask what the median student experience looks like, not the best one. Ask what assumptions sit behind the number, such as training several days a week. And note what nobody can tell you in advance: how your own progress will go.
Why “where did this come from?” is the key question
Notice the pattern in every claim above. The statement itself is not the useful part. The useful part is tracing it to its origin: the regulator’s rule, the device approval, the school’s actual records. Once you know the origin, you know how much weight to give the claim.
This habit is not unique to aviation. People researching health and cosmetic treatments face the same flood of glossy promises and dramatic photos. A resource such as Best Cosmetic Hospitals, an informational site on cosmetic surgery and treatment travel, says it ties its guides to named references like the NHS so readers can see what each statement leans on. Different subject, same principle: good information shows its homework.
A simple way to organise what you learn
As you research training options, try sorting every simulator claim into three columns:
- Confirmed: you have seen the regulation, approval or record yourself.
- Stated: a reliable person mentioned it, yet the underlying document is still missing from your notes.
- Unknown: nobody can answer yet, or the answer depends on you.
The goal is not to move everything into the first column. Some things will always sit in the third. The goal is to know which column each claim belongs in before you sign up, pay a deposit or plan your year around it.
Questions worth asking any school
- Which category of device do you use, and what is it approved for?
- Which parts of my training will be in the device, and which in the aircraft?
- Where can I read the rule that sets the limits on simulator time for my licence?
- What does a typical, not fastest, training timeline look like here?
- What tends to cause delays?
Asking these questions is not rude or suspicious. Instructors are used to students who think carefully, and many prefer them.
The takeaway
Simulators are a genuinely valuable part of modern pilot training. They let you practise procedures, failures and decisions safely and repeatedly. Just keep the claims about them in perspective. Ask where each one comes from, read the source that actually decides it, and be comfortable writing “not yet known” next to anything you cannot confirm. That habit will serve you long after you have finished your training.