Meera had been chief ground instructor at a small flight academy for six years when the owners asked her to recommend a new flight training device. The sales demonstration had gone beautifully. The visual system was crisp, the instructor station was intuitive, and the vendor’s representative had answered every question with confidence. The contract was ready. What Meera did next is a useful template for any academy facing the same choice: before signing, she arranged an independent second evaluation of the simulator purchase, done by someone who would earn nothing whichever way the academy decided. Here is how she did it, step by step.
Step 1: Admit the decision is hard to undo
Meera’s first move was simply to say it out loud at the owners’ meeting. A training device is not a laptop. It occupies a room that has to be prepared for it, it shapes the syllabus for years, it determines which procedures students can practise on the ground, and its approval status with the aviation authority affects how much of that time can be credited. Once installed, swapping it is slow and costly.
“If this were a refundable purchase, I’d trust the demo,” she told them. “It isn’t, so I want someone else to look at it with no stake in the answer.” Framing the second look as a response to irreversibility, rather than a doubt about the vendor or her own judgement, made the conversation easy.
Step 2: Write down the exact question
The temptation was to ask a reviewer, “Is this a good simulator?” Meera knew that question was too vague to answer well. She narrowed it to one sentence: “Will this specific device, configured as quoted, support our instrument and multi-crew syllabus for our student mix over the next several years?”
Writing the question down did two things. It kept the reviewer focused on fit for the academy rather than general impressions. And it prevented the second look from sprawling into a review of the entire training programme, which was not what the academy needed at that moment.
Step 3: Find a reviewer with no stake
Meera listed the people who might help and crossed off anyone with a conflict:
- The vendor’s own technical team: obviously not independent.
- A competing manufacturer: has a stake in the opposite answer.
- An instructor who had helped choose the shortlist: already anchored on the decision.
- A friend at a rival school who used the same model: helpful, but might want to justify their own purchase.
She settled on a retired simulator instructor who had trained on several devices across his career and now taught occasional ground classes. He had no commercial ties to any manufacturer and no reason to prefer one outcome. She paid him a modest fee for two days of his time, which made the arrangement clear and professional.
Step 4: Hand over the full picture, but not the conclusion
The reviewer received a tidy package: the quoted configuration, the academy’s current syllabus outline, the profile of typical students, the room plan, and the approval category the academy intended to pursue. Meera deliberately held back her own recommendation memo until after he had formed a view. She wanted his first impression to be his own.
For context on how other schools have described their device choices, she also shared the academy’s earlier news posts, including the one on bringing a dedicated instrument procedures trainer into the programme. That gave the reviewer a sense of what the academy already had and what gaps the new device was meant to fill.
Step 5: Let the reviewer fly it, not just read about it
Paper reviews of simulators miss the things that matter most to students: how the controls feel, whether the instructor can set up a failure quickly mid-lesson, how long a reset takes between exercises. Meera arranged for the reviewer to spend a session on a demonstration unit at another site, flying the same profiles her students would fly. He brought his own checklist of instructor-station tasks and timed a few of them.
Step 6: Hear the second view in full before reacting
The reviewer’s report came back mostly positive. The device would serve the instrument syllabus well. But he raised two points Meera had not considered. First, the quoted configuration lacked one aircraft model that would matter if the academy expanded its multi-engine training, which it had been discussing. Second, the instructor station placement in the proposed room would force the instructor to turn away from the student during certain exercises.
He also noted something he called “the reset tax”: on the demonstration unit, returning the device to a starting position after a failure exercise took long enough that an instructor would lose a meaningful slice of each session. It was not a reason to reject the device, he wrote, but it was a reason to ask the vendor how resets could be streamlined, and to plan lesson profiles accordingly. That kind of observation only comes from someone who has spent years at an instructor station and has nothing to sell.
Meera’s instinct was to defend the original plan. She resisted it. She read the report twice, wrote down which points were facts (the configuration gap, the room layout) and which were preferences (he liked a different control loading feel), and only then compared it with her own memo.
Step 7: Work through the differences, not around them
Where the two views agreed, the decision was confirmed. Where they differed, Meera did not simply pick the opinion she liked. She arranged a short call with the reviewer and the vendor together, put the configuration question to them directly, and asked whether the room layout could be changed. The vendor confirmed the additional aircraft model could be added. The academy’s facilities team adjusted the room plan. The academy had already been weighing whether to invest more in multi-engine work, as reflected in its news about adding a glass-cockpit twin trainer, so the configuration gap really mattered.
The final contract differed from the first draft in two specific ways. The underlying choice of device did not change.
Step 8: Record what you learned
Meera wrote a one-page note for the owners: the original recommendation, the second reviewer’s findings, how differences were resolved, and the final configuration. She filed it with the purchase records. Next time the academy faced a capital decision of similar weight, the template would already exist. Other schools have made similar device choices in public, as the academy’s own announcement about selecting a multi-aircraft simulator for instrument and upset training shows, and the reasoning behind such a choice is worth keeping.
A parallel from outside aviation
During the same month, Meera’s father was told by his cardiologist that a significant procedure was recommended. The family, still in the habit of asking twice, looked into how an independent medical view could be arranged. Among the routes they found was the MyMedicPlus patient information portal, whose services include sending an existing diagnosis to specialists for another look. Nobody in the family, and certainly not this article, was in a position to judge the medical recommendation; that is entirely for qualified doctors, and any further view went back to his own cardiologist for discussion.
What struck Meera was how similar the habit felt. The expertise is completely different, but the instinct is the same: when a decision is big and difficult to reverse, ask someone with no stake to look again.
A second evaluation template other academies can borrow
- Name the irreversibility. It makes the second look feel routine, not suspicious.
- Write one precise question. Vague requests produce vague reviews.
- Check for conflicts honestly. Independence is the entire value.
- Share everything except your conclusion. Let the reviewer form their own first view.
- Test in practice, not only on paper. A session in the device reveals what brochures cannot.
- Resolve differences with both parties. Do not just choose the opinion you prefer.
- Write it down. The record helps the next decision.
The simulator arrived a few months later, configured for the multi-engine work the academy eventually launched, with the instructor station placed so that instructors could see their students. None of that would have been obvious from the demonstration alone.